Log In
Colgate Ave, Elyria, OH 44035
Log In
Properties (74)
We found 74 addresses and 74 properties on Colgate Avenue in Elyria, OH. The average price for real estate on Colgate Avenue is $40,810. The average property tax on Colgate Avenue is $2,411/yr and the average house or building was built in 1963. The average household income in the Colgate Avenue area is $51,945. Select an address below to search who owns that property on Colgate Avenue and uncover many additional details. We found 74 addresses and 74 properties on Colgate Avenue in Elyria, OH. The average price for real estate on Colgate Avenue is $40,810. The average property tax on Colgate Avenue is $2,411/yr and the average house or building was built in 1963. The average household income in the Colgate Avenue area is $51,945. Select an address below to search who owns that property on Colgate Avenue and uncover many additional details. See More...
Search through the addresses below and select an address to view additional details about the property.
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
944 sq ft
0.18 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1971
$89,730 est.
$1,971/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.5K sq ft
0.18 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1972
$124,270 est.
$2,179/yr taxes
2 stories
3-4 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.19 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1971
$95,820 est.
$1,555/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.2K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1968
$99,860 est.
$1,644/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
944 sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1971
$92,900 est.
$1,491/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.5K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1968
$120,940 est.
$2,655/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
944 sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1971
$100,040 est.
$2,196/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.2K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1968
$101,630 est.
$2,231/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
962 sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1971
$98,270 est.
$2,157/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1966
$107,220 est.
$2,414/yr taxes
2 stories
3-4 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.9K sq ft
0.2 acre
3 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$130,280 est.
$2,860/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.7K sq ft
0.24 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1966
$121,740 est.
$2,124/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2K sq ft
0.19 acre
5 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1966
$140,990 est.
$2,551/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
9 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.9K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$129,030 est.
$2,833/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$127,710 est.
$2,255/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$121,950 est.
$2,679/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
9 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
3.3K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1965
$139,970 est.
$3,073/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.7K sq ft
0.22 acre
5 beds / 4 baths
Built in 1964
$171,790 est.
$3,772/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
9 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.8K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$146,850 est.
$3,224/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
8 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.9K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1965
$138,610 est.
$3,044/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
8 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.19 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$111,910 est.
$2,457/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.9K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$131,460 est.
$2,337/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.23 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1964
$120,270 est.
$2,641/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.19 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$130,890 est.
$2,874/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.9K sq ft
0.19 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$136,400 est.
$2,995/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.9K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1966
$106,270 est.
$2,334/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.2K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1963
$151,640 est.
$2,781/yr taxes
2 stories
3-4 car garage
8 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.2K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 4 baths
Built in 1964
$163,130 est.
$3,582/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1963
$116,510 est.
$2,009/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.8K sq ft
0.19 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1965
$129,340 est.
$2,291/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.5K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1965
$133,750 est.
$2,936/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.7K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$125,810 est.
$2,214/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.6K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1963
$124,070 est.
$2,794/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.7K sq ft
0.22 acre
5 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1964
$163,420 est.
$3,588/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
10 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1963
$106,560 est.
$2,340/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.19 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1962
$112,900 est.
$2,479/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.2K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1965
$103,820 est.
$2,279/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1963
$114,440 est.
$2,513/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.9K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1965
$124,140 est.
$2,177/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1965
$136,560 est.
$2,998/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.7K sq ft
0.22 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1962
$131,020 est.
$2,877/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.28 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1963
$137,330 est.
$3,017/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.2 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$85,110 est.
$1,869/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.1K sq ft
0.22 acre
2 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1960
$114,570 est.
$2,516/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
4 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.26 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1963
$106,360 est.
$2,395/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.2 acre
3 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1959
$116,300 est.
$2,553/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.1K sq ft
0.17 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1965
$143,620 est.
$2,604/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.19 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$114,350 est.
$1,962/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.2K sq ft
0.16 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1961
$116,570 est.
$2,624/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
8 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$88,420 est.
$1,393/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.16 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$102,930 est.
$1,711/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$103,930 est.
$2,282/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$97,580 est.
$2,142/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.2K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1962
$89,500 est.
$1,965/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.2K sq ft
0.16 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1960
$135,790 est.
$2,982/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.16 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1971
$110,680 est.
$2,430/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.6K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1961
$111,260 est.
$1,894/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.1K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1961
$88,460 est.
$1,942/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.5K sq ft
0.16 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$112,510 est.
$2,470/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.16 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$102,270 est.
$2,245/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.7K sq ft
0.2 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1961
$124,010 est.
$2,792/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.16 acre
4 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$95,750 est.
$2,102/yr taxes
2 stories
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.7K sq ft
0.2 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$131,350 est.
$1,787/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
7 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$109,600 est.
$2,468/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.2 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1961
$109,200 est.
$2,398/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
950 sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1960
$85,830 est.
$1,886/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.4K sq ft
0.21 acre
3 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1955
$114,800 est.
$1,972/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.2K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1962
$93,740 est.
$2,058/yr taxes
1 story
3-4 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.2K sq ft
0.25 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$101,710 est.
$2,290/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.3K sq ft
0.3 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$107,020 est.
$2,350/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
2.4K sq ft
0.28 acre
4 beds / 3 baths
Built in 1962
$160,310 est.
$3,520/yr taxes
2 stories
3-4 car garage
9 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.5K sq ft
0.16 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1960
$76,650 est.
$1,683/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
912 sq ft
0.17 acre
3 beds / 2 baths
Built in 1961
$84,010 est.
$1,891/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
5 rooms total
POSSIBLE OWNERS & RESIDENTS
FEATURES
1.2K sq ft
0.22 acre
3 beds / 1 bath
Built in 1960
$83,090 est.
$1,824/yr taxes
1 story
1-2 car garage
6 rooms total
Search for Property Data on
Property Search
Owner Search
Overview
Click on a property below to see photos, lot size, property type and additional details.
Average sq ft
8.7K sq ft
Average Value
$40,810
Biggest House
3.3K sq ft
Largest Lot
0.3 acre
Nearby Streets
Click on a street below to learn about properties on that street. Search for owner's names, deed records, property tax, mortgage information and more.
| Street Name | Properties | Avg. Value | Avg. Lot Size | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Street Name | Bellfield Ave, Elyria, OH | Properties | 88 | Avg. Value | $24,409 | Avg. Lot Size | 5.2K sq ft |
| Street Name | Broad St, Elyria, OH | Properties | 252 | Avg. Value | $92,156 | Avg. Lot Size | 42.8K sq ft |
| Street Name | Ashland Ave, Elyria, OH | Properties | 42 | Avg. Value | $59,873 | Avg. Lot Size | 11.9K sq ft |
| Street Name | Antoinette St, Elyria, OH | Properties | 19 | Avg. Value | $37,489 | Avg. Lot Size | 11.1K sq ft |
| Street Name | 11th St, Elyria, OH | Properties | 59 | Avg. Value | $26,171 | Avg. Lot Size | 6.2K sq ft |
| Street Name | Bowling Green Cir, Elyria, OH | Properties | 39 | Avg. Value | $35,691 | Avg. Lot Size | 7.6K sq ft |
Nearby Streets With Highest Property Values
Browse nearby streets with the highest average property values. Click on a street to see additional details about properties on that street.
| Street Name | Properties | Avg. Value | Avg. Lot Size | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Street Name | Chestnut Commons Dr, Elyria, OH | Properties | 10 | Avg. Value | $2,255,568 | Avg. Lot Size | 231.4K sq ft |
| Street Name | Market Dr, Elyria, OH | Properties | 6 | Avg. Value | $1,554,854 | Avg. Lot Size | 320.4K sq ft |
| Street Name | Midway Mall, Elyria, OH | Properties | 11 | Avg. Value | $1,367,584 | Avg. Lot Size | 417.9K sq ft |
| Street Name | Infirmary Rd, Elyria, OH | Properties | 22 | Avg. Value | $710,993 | Avg. Lot Size | 373.9K sq ft |
| Street Name | Taylor Pkwy, Elyria, OH | Properties | 14 | Avg. Value | $441,306 | Avg. Lot Size | 211.9K sq ft |
| Street Name | Leona St, Elyria, OH | Properties | 10 | Avg. Value | $366,326 | Avg. Lot Size | 81K sq ft |
Nearby Amenities
HOSPITAL
Emh Regional Medical Center
630 East River Street
Elyria, OH
1.5 miles away
COLLEGE
Oberlin College
70 N Professor St
Oberlin, OH
13 miles away
AIRPORT
Carrolls (OI22)
Elyria, OH
2.6 miles away
GROCERY STORE
East River Road Convenient
905 E River St
Elyria, OH
1.4 miles away
CELL TOWER
Elyria, City Of
Fire Stn #2 330 E Broad St
Elyria, OH
1.4 miles away
FIRE STATION
Elyria Fire Department Station 2
330 E Broad St
Elyria, OH
1.4 miles away
POLITICAL VOTING
Leans Democratic
Demographics
The largest ethnic group in the Colgate Ave area is White at 76.2% followed by Black at 12.8%. In terms of education, 36% have High School followed by 35.6% with Some College. 36.5% of the population in the area is Non-Family and the largest age group is 20-29 making up 14.5% of the population.
The ethnicity found on this street may be represented as 0.7% Asian, 12.8% Black, 5.4% Hispanic, 76.2% White and 5.0% Other.
The education levels found on this street may be represented as 5.8% Graduate Degree, 10.2% Bachelors Degree, 35.6% Some College, 36.0% High School, and 12.3% No Diploma.
The age distribution found on this street may be represented as 10.4% 70+, 11.8% 60-69, 14.3% 50-59, 12.1% 40-49, 11.7% 30-39, 14.5% 20-29, 12.3% 10-19, and 12.8% 0-9.
The household types found on this street may be represented as 12.4% Married with Kids, 27.6% Married without Kids, 13.2% Single with Kids, 10.3% Single without Kids, and 36.5% Non-Family.
Search for Property Data on
Property Search
Owner Search
Get more out of your property search
Get more out of your property search
Need a Real Estate Agent?
Looking to buy or sell a property in Elyria area?
Thank you!
Your message has been received. A real estate agent will review it shortly. You can expect a response within 3-5 business days.
By clicking “Get Connected”, you are agreeing to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, and are agreeing to receive marketing email messages from NeighborWho and/or marketing emails, calls or texts placed by or on behalf of a NeighborWho affiliate, to any phone number and/or email address that you provided, even if your number is on a federal, state, or our internal Do Not Call List. You further agree that call/texts may be sent with an automated system for selection or dialing of numbers. Please note: Consent is not a condition of purchase. Standard data and messaging rate may apply. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Want to advertise here?
